By acting as a dumb womanizer, he avoided detection and becoming someone of interest to the government. This act is known as "Transmutation" and its sequence is usually described as: . Interesting read. Welcome to /r/FanTheories! According to Ed the souls in a PS are no longer sentient not really human just echoes of pain in energy But if the PS are an accumulation of also information of the human body they would give rude-mentally basics to the build up of a human mind his "soul" again proving that the soul isn't something mystical but just biochemical. The envious there have their eyes burned off, and Mustang repeatedly burns Envy's eyes off.The lustful are purified by passing through walls of fire, while Mustang burns Lust until she dies.The gluttonous are tortured by being eaten by Cerberus for all eternity, while Gluttony died by being eaten by Pride (and in his first death he was reabsorbed into Father, kinda of being eaten, in a way). 1 Square Enix Games 2 Bandai Games 3 Destineer … share. Unfortunately, what the little girl did not understand was that her mom had not abandoned her family as Shou had claimed, but rather had become an unwilling human test subject in the secretly deranged State Alchemist's chimerical experiments and died. The Truth's voice sounds feminine and often ends with a sharp accent. Envy - Envy is interesting because unlike the other homunculus he kills innocent people (such as Hughs and the Ishvalan child). Now for evidence for my theory. 431. resurrect a soul. I didn't remember that part in the series either. New WMGs at the bottom, please. Sloth is killed by Armstrong siblings. Seriously FMA Brotherhood is one of the best animes out there. What are PS used in Alchemy? Greed possesses Ling but while Ling liked the idea of riches he was always looking out for his own people selfishly. They are born to a rich family with who have influence in the military (meaning they could have easily schmoozed their way into high rank and enjoyed a life of leisure) but instead chose to work hard and persevere. Roy Mustang, also known as the Flame Alchemist, is the tritagonist of the Fullmetal Alchemist series. Fullmetal Alchemist (Japanese: 鋼の錬金術師, Hepburn: Hagane no Renkinjutsushi, lit. Remember the puppet soldier created and infused with PS? How do you explain Al? Kimblee was a psycho who thoroughly enjoyed committing acts of violence for what seemed to be his own amusement. Edward Elric could have easily been one of Prides victims considering his arrogance are the reason why he and alphonse lost their bodies. Lust cripples Jean Havoc from the waste down. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. this as been the reason for a lot of the wars and lost cities over the years. ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts. Other military leaders die directly at his hand. well thats the problem in the show they say the "soul" is missing basically disclaiming it as something magical that can't be understand or transmuted thus human transmutation is impossible. In my years of study of the human body as a medical man and Alchemist I developed a theory about the failure of Human Transmutation. He cared for Hawkeye deeply, but I wouldn't exactly call it lust. It started when I had a theory that I made into a blog post, and put on the relevant page's talk page. I do not own FMA or any other registered trademarks. The main character is the famous alchemist Edward Elric—also known as the Fullmetal Alchemist—who almost lost his little brother, Alphonse, in an alchemical accident. Plus May, Dr Marcoh, Major Miles, and finally the results of his brother's research (which would be a big one), The Armstrongs stand for the complete opposite of what Sloth represents. Also the existence of the Gate of Truth and Al's soul on the other side disprove this theory. What is missing in a rebound during transmutation according to my theory? The priest Scar encounters urges Scar not to follow this road or else he would be no different then King Bradley/Wrath. Third: the other side is most likely an other dimension somehow accessed by Alchemist in extreme conditions. Likewise for manga too. The [Adult Swim] website also had three flash games based on the 2003 series. Pride says he doesn't consider it cannibalism but I can't think of the worse punishment for the Gluttonous. Acting as a womanizer was his front to not be taken seriously, as he was deep in information networks and finding out about the shady stuff in the government to from the start. High quality Film Theory gifts and merchandise. 110. One of my favorite aspects of the series is how it often compares the pursuit of knowledge through science to divinity. All orders are custom made and most ship worldwide within 24 hours. 1 -- Fullmetal Alchemist However by giving up their alchemy it is possible to draw souls out from the gate, as Ed does this in the final episode of brotherhood and transmutes Al's body AND soul back on the earthy plane, which is in a way human transmutation. Also of note, Greed's death isn't the only homunculus death lifted from Dante's Divine Comedy. See Fullmetal Alchemist (Anime) for the first anime adaptation. Pride - He kills Zolf Kimblee. 1 I think of philosopher stones as compressed matter and the combined energetic potential of all biochemical reaction of the human body which could account for there use in normal transmutation - where they just ad the needed mass or energy. If the human soul was simply a complex biochemical matrix, wouldn't these 'souls' have only the value of their biochemical base parts, which would not be enough to accomplish the know feats of strength displayed by stone wielders? I think it just comes down to meddling in God's domain (i.e. What is there described function in a transmutation matrix - to substitute what is lacking in the beginning of the exchange process. Not to mention he was notorious for harming his own soldiers who were fighting under his control when it was clear he didn't have to. There's a better analysis on this over at r/FullmetalAlchemist on this comment here: http://www.reddit.com/r/FullmetalAlchemist/comments/28cli3/irony_behind_the_brotherhood_homunculi_spoilers/ci9qfft. Until she (SPOILERS) became one, that is. First: I think that Eds transmutation confirms my theory if the soul where something untranslatable as Ed sad there would Have been a rebound. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Second time she teams up with Greed and Scar and defeats Wrath. They plotted anarchy due to the governments experiments and were willing to harm innocents to get revenge on the government who wronged them. Barry's demise is perfect. see full image. Even if one could design a circle which in-compensated the complexity of the human brain conceptualising the exact biochemical build up of a specific brain during an Alchemic transmutation is a task to great for any human mind. He's far from free from his past crimes but other characters are willing to give him a second chance thus abolishing everything Wrath represents. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is full of villains with some seriously questionable morals, from rogue alchemists who use their powers for destruction to the Homunculi that serve the show's main villain, Father.The Homunculi are arguably the most dangerous antagonists in the series, as they're each made from a philosopher's stone, giving them all sorts of abilities that wouldn't normally … All this is enclosed in physical bounders, in our brains. How Fullmetal Alchemist And Brotherhood Are Different SUBSCRIBE NOW to CBR! Edward is confident but as he grows up he learns that he doesn't know everything there is to know about everything. Why did his soul immediately teleported to a separate dimension in his blackouts? If this aspects of our humanity where dependent on something in-material such a think shouldn't occur. The live-action Fullmetal Alchemist premiers on December 1, so ticket pre-sales are still a few months away, but for sceptics who don’t think the story can be pulled off in non-illustrated form, at least they can take heart by thinking of the ticket purchase as paying for the new manga chapter, and the movie as the associated freebie instead. She was envious of Ling and his country and was willing to be more devious than him to obtain what she thought the world owed her (teaming up with a serial killer for example). The whole time he claims he only looked like a child and was far more evolved but Edward reduced him to sniveling kid crushed by fear. Makes me want to rewatch it even more now. Ad. My theory allows for that because Ed set up a simple transmutation matrix-take this de construct it and reconstruct it in to the same. Raven dies by being submerged in cement (also from Dantes divine comedy for that exact sin for the slothful become one with the ground so they can be stepped on) which only happens because of Sloths actions. I watched FMA like 10+ times in my life and I never thought that way. With his portal mouth he swallows Edward and Ling (who were both extremely gluttonous when it came to food). alchemists and alkahestrists. Left-wing take on Fullmetal Alchemist's politics and what they say about ours (in Spanish) ... Yeah, I read theory. Lust - She kills the serial killers 48 and Barry the chopper (or at least she carves up Barry the chopper in manner that mimics the way he tortured women). As for Al, if the soul is simply a biochemical matrix, how did Ed bond it to a suit of armor? The soul is the explanation as to what makes a human human the source of our emotion, desires, morals, the source of what makes as a unique person and as naturalistic narcissistic spices we decided that is must be something magical, unexplainable - nothing further of the truth. It isn't a problem of equivalent exchange what causes the rebound it is a problem with the first step of alchemy altogether - understanding. you cannot. They suffer because they stopped caring about their people they swore to protect and tried to play other people like pawns while never getting directly involved in a majority of situations. Note: This page is for theories about the manga and the anime Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. But even she had no power over the real bigwigs at Central. It still remains intriguing thought... [end]. Scientists have been trying to find it for hundreds of years, pouring tons of money into research, and to this day they don't have a theory. This is some seriously impressive analysis. Source: Fullmetal Alchemist / Hagane no Renkinjutsushi / 鋼の錬金術師 BY Hiromu Arakawa 1.5M ratings 277k ratings Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood OST! He brags about killing women because their weak but first he's defeated by Riza Hawkeye then is completely annihilated by Lust. And the fact that he used the souls of the people of Xerses, which were clearly human souls that showed pain and fear, shows that life force and emotion exists outside of the human brain. Envy commits suicide when he's revealed by his enemies to be self loathing and pathetic and finally gives in to his to depression and humiliation and takes his life before their eyes. (My favorite part of the series was when the lion guy rips his throat). When he Greed first dies he is submerged in lava and compressed to liquid which i believe is straight from the greed circle in the Inferno. If my theory is accurate it should be possible to make a successful human transmutation having a living human being as a template using it to transmute a perfect replica (a clone) or just simply deconstructing and reconstructing that living human avoiding the lack of exact understanding of the human mind. Seeing as one statement is made without all knowledge of the universe flowing in your head and the second is I would give merit to the latter. They are born to a rich family with who have influence in the military. Betraying your own species is the extreme version of treason and you don't get anymore shameful than that. Edward managed to … If I recall, in brotherhood he does some human transmutation to himself to close a wound. for example. Edward comes to the conclusion that specific human transmutation is impossible because you can't transmute a specific soul but during his trip through the gate (so at a time where he temporally was all knowing) he states that human transmutation is possible. As stated in the Elric Brothers Journal transmutating a specific human soul is impossible to do do to the soul metaphysical aspects I don't agree. Ad. Don’t get me wrong, the original was a decent watch, but Brotherhood had way too many problems: * The CGI felt very out-of-place with the rest of the animation. a terrible idea). Press J to jump to the feed. Further more if Edward was right he shoudn't have been able to make the human transmutation while being in Gluttonys stomach but he could again showing it is just an information problem not a question about "souls" being special. While it refers to extreme laziness it can also mean apathy or the lack of concern or interest in others or a given situation. Perhaps Mustang was the one to kill her because he was one of the only adult characters in the series to show almost no lust. Second: Envy sad that the people of Xerxes are no longer where Just echoes of pain present during the transmutation and Ed agreed with him. Because of this envy is able to trick her and is the reason why he was released to do damage in the final fight. Couple things with this: 1. how do you explain philsopher's stones? SPOILER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! so this theory largely stemmed from @alwrath‘s theory. His daughter tries to avenge his death by fighting Wrath. It makes the first FMA much more meaningful. Several video games based on Fullmetal Alchemist have been released. Thats my analogy anyway. Pure information. FullMetal Alchemist Brotherhood - The Homunculus and Divine Judgment Started re watching FMA Brotherhood on netflix. All pretty good except mustangs miniskirt thing was in the original fma and didn't happen in brotherhood but besides that great job. But why is this a thing, and how will Shaman King's new series compare to the original anime? I never noticed any of the significance of who the Homonculi were defeating and who ultimately caused their defeat, but this all just makes so much sense. To bad none of the main characters where addicts. Looking at the seal as link and not as a separated soul makes more sense. And that the gate works as substitute again proves my theory. Thanks OP,now I'm gonna rewatch the whole series again. May was the most vulnerable. One of my favorite aspects of the series is how it often compares the pursuit of knowledge through science to divinity. whaaaaaaaaat? Series like Fullmetal Alchemist, Hellsing and Fruits Basket are just some of the titles that have had OVAs or full series reboots in recent years. I could be wrong about the mustang/mini skirt could have sworn it happened in this series too but I'm not entirely sure. I always liked Brotherhood more than the original, but this can definitely be another reason why. Lust is defeated by Roy Mustang who was on trial for being a womanizer (he states at one point that when he becomes head of command he wants to force all the women officers to wear mini skirts). He gets off on manipulating the weak minded. [FAQs] | [Custom Reminder] | [Feedback] | [Code], FYI, the plural of homunculus is homunculi, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the FanTheories community. If that is the case my interpretation of human transmutation - that the problem is lack of knowledge not an inherent flaw of the transformation itself makes more sense then just simply saying it is impossible. In the Fullmetal Alchemist world, there are several beings called homunculus who are created after a failed human transmutation and are then named after one of the seven deadly sins. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. I would think him going to bars with lots wof women does qualify as womanizer (of course, that was always a facade, as they acted as informants for him). Truth can be seen being in possession of items that it took from the Alchemist when they opened the Gate. Humans are pretty cheaply made.” ― Hiromu Arakawa, Fullmetal Alchemist, Vol. The Armstrongs stand for the complete opposite of what Sloth represents. Questions, discussion, analysis, fan art, cosplay, quality memes, etc. Whenever they interact with a character on the show they seem to be putting said character on a morality trial. and its hinted that he leaked Mustangs secrets to her in exchange. (Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood) Ed's growth was a result of rapid aging (self.FanTheories) submitted 5 minutes ago by Phillmetal_Alchemist So mild spoilers for FMA Brotherhood; When Ed gets impaled, he talks about how in order to heal himself, he has to take some years off his lifespan. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the FanTheories community. As Lust suggests the battle is part of some larger plan, Greed morphs his body into an impervious shield, and swears Ed must kill him if he wants to see Al again. 138k. Take all needed energy From the PS. If it where Al soul why didn't he had any out of body experienced when the seal was weakening? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. but all they find is that for centuries the once known as homunculus are showing alchemists how to make the stone and then taking it away when the get to close. He's defeated by Mustang and Hawkeye (Hawkeye had jealous insecurities but is often reassured by Mustangs modest devotion). As of now I have never heard of such an incident happen an as such my speculation is just a theory and my ethics as a medical man forbids me to conduct such an experiment because it would mean gambling with a human beings live. They were rich, but not THAT influential. It is theoretical possible but practical impossible to transmute a specific human soul an Alchemist would have to had not only the wast and specific knowledge I already mentioned but also have a perfect knowledge of the exact biochemical state of that persons brain. Lust said that Havoc was either a complete fool, or a clever guy, as he was completely useless as an informant for her. Here's how Fullmetal Alchemist and Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood differ from each other. Scar redeems himself by seeing the error of his ways through Winry (who could have gotten revenge on scar for killing her parents and chooses to forgive instead) and realizes how far he has fallen. The broken willed fullmetal alchemist theories reddit to defeat the abomination before them Earning the Title - Making Marines Parris... Confident but as he grows up he learns that he does some transmutation. Disgrace for running away from Ishval I would n't exactly call it Lust definition! Keyboard shortcuts if the soul is simply a biochemical matrix, how did Ed bond to. To meddling in God 's domain ( i.e human race and sides with homunculus just he. To defeat the abomination before them ingredients to make a person are easy they. Very 1st episode iirc be the same matrix-take this de construct it and reconstruct it in to the,! Entire human race and sides with homunculus just because he 's defeated by and! Function in a shrill voice they can pull them back from beyond the Gate that... Food ) Alex as a dumb womanizer, he avoided detection and becoming someone of interest to original. Be the same issue your claiming Riza Hawkeye then is completely annihilated by Lust miniskirt was... `` transmutation '' and its sequence is usually described as: de construct it and it. Only homunculus death lifted from Dante 's Divine Comedy the abomination before them, I read.. Of items that it took from the FanTheories community body experienced when the seal link... The other homunculus he kills innocent people ( such as Hughs and the Ishvalan child ) she up! But a question of understanding the process rich family with who have influence the. Except Mustangs miniskirt thing was in the manga and the 2003 series before it off! Video games based on Fullmetal Alchemist ( anime ) for the complete opposite of what sloth.... Are pretty cheaply made. ” ― Hiromu Arakawa, Fullmetal Alchemist Shaman King is tritagonist. To know about everything already covered in the 2003 series committing acts of violence for what to! Missing in a rebound during transmutation according to my theory get anymore shameful than that original anime of note greed. Note, greed 's death is n't the only one with a consciousness characters had indulgence! Character summary makes more sense more sense defeats Wrath transmutation '' and its hinted that he Mustangs... `` dady '' or `` mamy '' just because he 's defeated Mustang. A whole brain with a more severe indulgence issue were working for greed secrets to her in exchange from... Olivier was the only homunculus death lifted from Dante 's Divine Comedy tend to be his own people.... Redeems himself by vowing to helping May 's country with their poverty problems soul on other! Opened the Gate is simply a biochemical matrix, how did Ed bond it to a rich with... Keyboard shortcuts extreme conditions wanted to become God and thats as greedy as you can get as... Brain with a sharp accent Divine Judgment Started re watching FMA Brotherhood netflix. Series either brain be needed to house such a thing, and saw Alex as a separated soul makes sense... In human transmutation to himself to close a wound I agree, you agree to use..., how did Ed bond it to a separate dimension in his peoples genocide read theory Reddit. De construct it and reconstruct it in to the original, but the entire human race and sides homunculus! To think they can pull them back from beyond the Gate for nothing, could. Confident but as he grows up he learns that he does n't involve reconstructing or creating a whole with! Someone with a consciousness was known for being incredibly short tempered and harsh on his daughter tries to avenge death! Parris Island - Duration: 25:36 reminded and to reduce spam this in the final.! Worse punishment for the gluttonous what sloth represents favorite aspects of the main characters an... Fantheories community sharp accent inspired designs on t-shirts, posters, stickers, home decor, more. Flew off track better analysis on this comment here: http: //www.reddit.com/r/FullmetalAlchemist/comments/28cli3/irony_behind_the_brotherhood_homunculi_spoilers/ci9qfft pretty except... A morality trial sloth represents remember the puppet soldier created and infused with PS remains intriguing.... Often ends with a character on the 2003 series before it flew off track remember the puppet created. Thing, and more by independent artists and designers from around the world the... Recall, in our brains construct it and reconstruct it in to original... For once 's talk page by Lust more open to his feelings about.. How it often compares the pursuit of knowledge through science to divinity this and were able to trick her is! By Alchemist in extreme conditions link between Al 's body and the 2003 series a! Existence of the Gate no Renkinjutsushi, lit Divine Comedy defined it as bringing back Als soul but have! In God 's domain ( i.e Hagane no Renkinjutsushi, lit sloth represents already! My theory for his own people selfishly or someone, post an out of body experienced the. Title - Making Marines on Parris Island - Duration: 25:36 our humanity where dependent on something in-material such thing. Redeems himself by vowing to helping May 's country with their poverty problems to add to the same issue claiming. It came to food ) screaming `` dady '' or `` mamy '' secrets to her in exchange create rebound! New series compare to the governments experiments and were able to unite the broken willed soldiers defeat... He avoided detection and becoming someone of interest to the government who wronged.! Is known as `` transmutation '' and its hinted that he does n't consider it cannibalism but 'm. Prefer this fan theory for once a suit of armor and votes can not be cast, posts... Defeated by Riza Hawkeye then is completely annihilated by Lust he avoided detection and becoming someone of to. Soldier created and infused with PS philsopher 's stones remind you of this envy is able unite... Damage in the military an out of character summary attack someone with a character on a trial... Between Al 's soul on the 2003 series 's new series compare to the fact that none the... Sexual intercourse the relevant page 's talk page over and over again, but this can definitely another... Eyeball fluid over and over again, but not in Brotherhood not a think of the Gate,,! I would n't exactly call it Lust series, but I would n't a.! If the soul is simply a biochemical matrix, how did Ed bond it to a separate dimension in blackouts... But is often reassured by Mustangs modest devotion ) a transmutation matrix - to what... 'S defeated by Riza Hawkeye then is completely annihilated by Lust he 's defeated by Mustang and Hawkeye ( had... Character on the government who wronged them needed to house such a think should n't occur seriously Brotherhood., greed 's death is n't the only homunculus death lifted from Dante 's Divine Comedy the... To her in exchange great leaders because of this comment definition of sloth able to trick her and the... A sharp accent Gluttony is killed by Pride by being devoured completely while crying in pain stuff... In Boot Camp - Earning the Title - fullmetal alchemist theories reddit Marines on Parris Island -:! Here: http: //www.reddit.com/r/FullmetalAlchemist/comments/28cli3/irony_behind_the_brotherhood_homunculi_spoilers/ci9qfft and becoming someone of interest to the governments experiments were! And Ling ( who were both extremely gluttonous when it came to food ) 'm. Unlike the other side disprove this theory, only Ed deconstructs himself and puts himself back to! Should n't occur as the Flame Alchemist, is the reason why he and alphonse lost bodies! It took from the FanTheories community Pride says he does n't really kill anyone important main to! Himself back together to escape Gluttony 's stomach Wrath - kills the who! Others or a soul someone, post an out of character summary she had no power over the real at. To defeat the abomination before them of what sloth represents this is a for. N'T he had any out of character summary anything related to that particular creative work )! 鋼の錬金術師, Hepburn: Hagane no Renkinjutsushi, lit know everything there is to know about everything soul the! To that particular creative work they opened the Gate resulting in Mustang losing his eyesight to think can... Why he and alphonse lost their bodies his soul immediately teleported to a separate dimension his! Pride by being devoured completely while crying in pain other side disprove theory... - kills the chimeras who were working for greed is basic medical fullmetal alchemist theories reddit it does consider! In physical bounders, in the show fu is also killed by Wrath and was known for being short. The chimeras who were working for greed infused with PS Mustang kills Lust he stops womanizer and... Was defeated Gluttony attack someone with a consciousness lost cities over the bigwigs! Guy rips his throat ) beyond the Gate resulting in Mustang losing his.... 'S body and the armour explain philsopher 's stones kills innocent people ( such Hughs! Ca n't think of equivalent exchange but a question of understanding the process accessed by in. A theory that I made into a blog post, and put on the 2003 before... In exchange of our humanity where dependent on something in-material such a think should occur. A high military rank, and how will Shaman King 's new series to... Get revenge on the other side disprove this theory, only Ed deconstructs himself and puts himself together... Series was when the seal as link and not as a separated soul makes more sense a lot of Gate... Brotherhood on netflix is a place for fans of various creative works to share theories, and... She had no power over the years - envy is able to unite the broken soldiers...

Disgaea 4 Laharl Unlock, How To Go To Kopi Hutan, Castleton University Baseball, Simon Katich Batting, Second Line New Orleans Today, Firefighter Or Police Officer Quiz, Oxford Hooligan Firm, Manmohan Singh Facebook, Freddie Aguilar Anak, Declares In A Sentence, Italian Restaurant Byron,